They ARE overdue for a meeting!! I would definitely be up for either scenario! I like the idea of him being able to help her dispel the lighthouse pull for her, he doesn't know what is causing it but he doesn't trust anything that causes you to do anything you don't want to.

On the other hand, he is 100% a bleeding heart and he will need people to slap sense into him so that he stops trying to save dead people on the boats too, sweats